What's the difference between a gag gift and a White Elephant gift?

A gag gift exists purely for the laugh and is usually given to one person; a White Elephant gift enters a stealing game, so it helps if it's funny and something people would keep.

How much should a gag gift cost?

Under $25 almost always. The joke is the value — spending more starts to read as an actual gift and confuses the bit.

Gag gifts

9 Gag Gifts That Are Actually Worth Wrapping

Joke gifts with staying power — they earn the laugh at the party and still get kept on a desk afterward.

Start here

Top picks

Representative green pickle toy with a button, mid-yodel on a table

The legendUnder $15

Yodelling Pickle Musical Toy

A pickle. That yodels. Repeatedly.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative tiny toy goat figurine standing on a tidy office desk

Desk chaosUnder $15

Screaming Goat Desk Figurine

Press the goat. It screams. That's it — and it's perfect.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative mini putting green set up on a bathroom floor

Gag classicUnder $15

Toilet Golf Putting Game

Finally, productive bathroom time.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

6 more

The full list

As an Amazon Associate, XmasGoat earns from qualifying purchases. Picks are chosen for the giving situation first; affiliate availability does not determine inclusion.

Representative stack of joke gift boxes printed with fake product designs

Wrap deceptionUnder $15

Prank Gift Boxes (set of 3)

Wrap a real gift in a box for a fake terrible product.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative inflatable dinosaur costume mid-stomp at a living room party

Party legend$50–$100

Inflatable T-Rex Costume

Whoever unwraps this MUST wear it for one round. House rules.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative bathroom at night lit by a colourful glow from the toilet bowl

Weirdly usefulUnder $15

Motion-Sensor Toilet Bowl Night Light

The 3 a.m. bathroom trip, but make it a rave.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative oversized salmon plush pillow draped across a couch

Absurd comfort$25–$50

Giant Salmon Plush Pillow (3 ft)

It's a fish. It's a pillow. It's a lifestyle.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative squirrel seated at a tiny picnic table mounted on a fence

Backyard comedy$15–$25

Squirrel Picnic Table Feeder

A tiny picnic table. For squirrels. You're welcome.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Representative mini punching ball mounted on an office desk beside a keyboard

Stress outlet$15–$25

Desktop Punching Ball (suction mount)

For inbox-zero rage, one desk at a time.

Choose Canada or the United States for local pricing.Read more

Good to know

What's the difference between a gag gift and a White Elephant gift?: A gag gift exists purely for the laugh and is usually given to one person; a White Elephant gift enters a stealing game, so it helps if it's funny and something people would keep.
How much should a gag gift cost?: Under $25 almost always. The joke is the value — spending more starts to read as an actual gift and confuses the bit.

Shop by person Browse by kind of gift Swipe the deck All occasion guides

Free tools · nothing to install

Then keep the rest of Christmas in one place

Draw Secret Santa names, track what you have bought, and share what you would love. It all runs in your browser.

Start your exchange — it's free